Wildlife Judging: Selecting Wildlife Management Practices

Introduction

Understanding wildlife management practices (WMPs) is a key component of 4-H Wildlife Judging, particularly Wildlife Management Practices (Activity 2) and Wildlife Management Plan (Activity 3-A).

For Wildlife Management Practices (Activity 2) youth complete individually. Juniors are asked to recommend management practices for 4 species that are pre-selected by the contest coordinators. The correct number of WMPs needed for each species is shared with the Juniors. Seniors are asked to recommend management practices for 6 species that are pre-selected by the contest coordinators. Seniors are not provided the number of WMPs.

Wildlife Management Practices

Youth will examine a site and read a scenario to learn more about the property and the management goals. The scenario (or field conditions) will typically contain the following information: history of the site, landowner objectives, property boundaries and size of tract, population conditions of some species, and any special considerations. An aerial map will also be provided. Based on the scenario information and their evaluation of the existing habitat on site, youth recommend WMPs necessary to manage wildlife and vegetative type.

The scenario will provide information about multiple species. Management recommendations in Activity 2 should consider each species listed separately. The WMPSs should be recommended as if each species was the only species (focal species) considered on the site. For example, if planting trees is needed for species #1 and species #4, it should be checked for both species. Additionally, if the population of species #2 increases, that increase does not affect the other species. This is different from what participants do for the Wildlife Management Plan (Activity 3). Each WMP should also be considered independently from other WMPs.

The national WHEP manual lists appropriate wildlife management practices for wildlife species within the Southeast Mixed and Outer Coastal Plain ecoregion. However, youth should avoid automatically checking a practice listed or a particular species. Simply memorizing the matrix of WMPs and wildlife species is not a workable strategy. Youth must take into consideration the scenario and site to determine if a WMP is needed.

For example, a youth should not automatically check the “Water Developments for Wildlife” for the prothonotary warbler, just because this is a potential practice. If the site has adequate water for this species (i.e., a large wetland or a well-established lake or river), this practice would not be appropriate. Another example for a practice that is not automatically applicable includes “Do Not Feed Wildlife.” If the property is state/federal land that doesn’t allow feeding of wildlife, you would not select this practice because it is not an allowable practice on that property.

It is important to consider practices that are already occurring on the site, which would typically be provided in the scenario. For example, if prescribed fire is regularly happening at the site and will continue, then “Set-back Succession” (which includes the sub-practice of prescribed fire) should not be selected as it is not currently needed (because it is happening).

The best strategy is to use the list provided in the manual as a list of potential practices to consider. Potential WMPs for species may or may not be appropriate under a given set of conditions and circumstances for a particular scenario.

For each species page(s) in the national WHEP manual, the possible practices are listed along with information regarding when that practice would be needed. This text explicitly states how and why a WMP would be needed for a particular species. For example, planting trees is a potential WMP for multiple species, including barred owland white-tailed deer. For barred wls, trees should be planted in large open areas to create future habitat. For white-tailed deer, trees should be planted in large open areas to maintain at least 30 to 40 percent forest cover and/or where mast producers are lacking, particularly oaks. This specific informationis from the individual species pages. Additionally, there is an entire section in the national WHEP manual that explains each practice in detail.

Study Tips

When preparing youth to recommend management practices, here is a general approach that can be helpful. First, read the scenario and determine the management goal for the species. Then, identify the habitat requirements and potential practices for the species. although resources are not allowed at the competition, it is highly encouraged to reference the national WHEP manual (particularly the species pages) during practices. Then, youth should assess the site and determine the availability of food, water, and cover in relation to the management goals. Then, determine which practices will supply the missing habitat requirements. Remember that not all practices are applicable to every species.

Example

In this example, the American bumble bee will be the focal species. It’s likely a scenario involving the American bumble bee would desire for their population to increase. In addition to the information provided in the scenario, youth should observe the site and identify any significant features. Then, youth should think about the habitat requirements (diet, water, and cover).

For the American bumble bee, this includes:
– Diet: nectar and pollen from a variety of flowering plants
– Water: require free-standing water and use it at the hive to regulate the temperature of the hive, feed young bees, and dilute stored honey
– Cover: undisturbed early successional ecosystems rich in flowering plants

Consider what is present and what might be lacking at the site. For example, there may be plenty of flowering plants that can be a source of diet and cover, but free-standing water may not be present.

Then, consider which wildlife management practices would apply to the American bumble bee. (Remember, for Activity 2, youth are simply selecting practices. For Activity 3A, they are writing about the practices in a narrative form.)

There are 8 practices that could potentially apply:
– Conservation Easement
– Edge Feathering
– Field Borders
– Livestock Management
– Plant Native Grasses and Forbs
– Set-back Succession
– Water Developments for Wildlife
– Wildlife or Fish Survey

For the purposes of the Georgia contest, some of these practices are typically always selected (e.g., conservation easement and set-back succession). Some practices (e.g., livestock management) may need to be determined based on the scenario. The remaining practices are likely determined by considering both the site and scenario.

This is one strategy for coaching youth in selecting wildlife management practices.

Wildlife Judging: Preparing Successful Management Plans

Introduction

The Wildlife Management Plan (Activity 3-A) is a key component during the Wildlife Judging contest. Youth work on teams (divided into Junior and Senior divisions) to observe a site with a scenario or field conditions (40 minutes) and then write a management plan (40 minutes).

Junior teams use the template (Appendix B) and answer the questions about 1 species (selected by the contest coordinator). The Junior focal species are one of the following species: the barred owl, eastern cottontail, American alligator, largemouth bass, or American bumble bee. Juniors do not prepare a formal management plan; they complete the questions on the template. Each Junior contestant will be given one sheet of paper to write notes on while o serving the site. Teams turn in the one template with the answers recorded on the template.

Seniors will write a 2-page (single-sided) management plan and provide an aerial map (1-page) for evaluation. For Seniors, the plan will address 2 species (selected by the contest coordinator) to be announced during the activity. The 2 focal species are selected from the 22 listed for the Southeast Mixed and Outer Coastal Plain Forest ecoregion. They will consider both species in the one plan. Compromises may likely be part of the plan (e.g., installing a food plot for one species could create an unintended increase in population for the other species). Each Senior contestant will be given one sheet of paper to write notes on while observing the site.

Junior Management Plan Template

Appendix B: Junior Wildlife Management Plan Template is completed by each Junior Team. Youth will work together to answer the series of questions about the focal species. Youth do not necessarily have to answer every question in complete sentences, but using complete sentences in certain sections (e.g., plan evaluation) would likely result in a higher score.

Appendix C: Junior Wildlife Management Plan Scoring Rubric is used to evaluate the plan. It is important to encourage youth to answer all components of the plan template. Not completing a section (e.g., aerial map) results in automatically earning 0 points for that section.

The remainder of this publication focuses on coaching Senior in writing an actual wildlife management plan. 

Wildlife Management

Typically, wildlife management can be categorized into four different types of goals:

– increase population, when dealing with endangered or threatened species or when populations are declining
– decrease population, when the population has grown beyond a reasonable size
– manage for a sustainable yield, ensuring that an annual harvest during hunting/trapping seasons (or periodic fishing) will allow for the population to remain healthy
– monitor the population, when essentially nothing is being done, other than periodic surveys

Youth will examine a site and read a scenario to learn more about the property and the management goals. Two focal species will be selected, and both species will be incorporated into the one plan. Compromises may likely be part of the plan (e.g., removing a food source for one species could create an unintended decrease in population for the other species).

The scenario (or field conditions) will typically contain the following information: history of the site, landowner objectives, property boundaries and size of tract, population conditions of some species, and any special considerations. An aerial map will also be provided.

Wildlife Management Plans

Writing the plan using an outline similar to the scoring rubric can be very helpful in organizing the information. Teams are encouraged to create sections/heading to clearly label information. Remember that teams are provided blank paper, so they should learn the order of information in preparation for the contest.

Initially, Senior teams may want to use Appendix B (Junior Wildlife Management Plan Template) to organize their information. The sections and questions align with an ideal management plan.

Background Information

A well-developed management plan will accurately identify the wildlife species to be managed and the management objectives.

The focus of this section is to provide an overview about the focal species, management goals, and the site. The site information (usually from the scenario or simple observation) can include information such as the size of the site, successional stage(s) represented, type of forest (young vs. mature, same tree species vs. mixed) present, bodies of water (e.g., lake, stream), and structures (e.g., building, roads, trails).

Tip: Think about the background information as a verbal description of the aerial map. An overview about all the important features should be explained. (Since this is the background component, sharing about the locations where the management practices would be implemented is not needed.)

An example of the background information for a management plan could be: Our family recently purchased this 200-acre property that was once a beef cattle farm. We plan to convert the area to a recreational retreat and specifically want to hunt white-tailed deer in the fall and wild turkey in the spring. There is one house and one barn on the property, with the intent of more cabins being added over the coming years. The field are primarily native perennial grasses with some brambles, likely in the second successional stage. As you transition from the fields downhill towards the stream at the south end of the property, a young pine forest has been planted, and various shrubs and small trees represent the third successional stage. Interspersion is low.

Plan Development

A well-developed management plan will demonstrate the team’s understanding of the habitat needs of each species, accurately evaluate the area as habitat for each species (what is present and what is lacking), and identify major native plant species or nonnative invasive species present.

The focus of this section is to describe the habitat assessment, the required habitat components for each species, and an assessment describing any required components that are missing, in poor condition, or in short supply. The habitat needs (food, water and cover) for each of the focal species. This information is found on the species page(s) in the national WHEP manual. Some species may have extensive habitat needs. For example, their diet changes throughout the seasons, or their diet differs from young/juveniles to adults. Others may need one type of cover for foraging and another type of cover for nesting. It is not imperative that every detail (e.g., northern bobwhite eat a variety of seeds, especially legumes, ragweed, crotons, lespedeza, etc.) be listed. However, the diet, water, and cover for both focal species should be listed. Youth are encouraged to note where there may be overlap in some of these requirements, which could lead to competition, compromises, etc.

The second part of this section addresses what is present at the site, including specifically referencing native and nonnative species. The plan will first state the food, water, and cover requirements of the species, and now it is time to determine what food, water, and cover is present and what is lacking. Teams will also identify major native plant species or nonnative invasive species present. This initial assessment will later inform which management practices are needed. For example, if a species needs mast for a food source and there are no mast-producing shrubs or trees, this would be noted in this section. Later, some of the recommended practices would be to plant shrubs (like wild plum) and plant trees (like oak and hickory) so that there would be a food source for that species.

Tip: Each youth gets on piece of paper for taking notes. Sometimes youth create a table to note what are the needs for each species and what is present and lacking on the site.

Species #1

Requirements for Species Present or Lacking?
Food
Water
Cover

Species #2

Requirements for Species Present or Lacking?
Food
Water
Cover

Teams may choose to present this information in a variety of ways. Some ideas include:

– writing about all the requirements for one species, then the requirements for the second species, and what is present/lacking at the site, specifically noting the native and nonnative invasive species
– writing about the food requirements for both species and what is present/lacking, then repeating this for the water and cover needs

An example of the plan development for a management plan could be: Wild turkey have an extremely varied diet. In the fall and winter, they need hard mast, such as acorns from oak trees. In the spring and summer, they eat soft mast, such as blackberries, mulberries, and black cherry. They also eat miscellaneous seeds and leaves from forbs.

White-tailed deer also have a varied diet, including forbs, browse, hard mast (like acorns), soft mast (such as blackberry and persimmon), grains, and even mushrooms. When observing the site, the fields have substantial grasses, forbs, and browse, which would satisfy both species. Partridge pea and goldenrod are abundant. The forest area is predominantly loblolly pine with a few cedars, sweetgums, and dogwoods. There is a need for shrubs and trees that would produce soft and hard mast for both species – blackberries, persimmon, black cherry, oak trees, beech trees, and hickory trees.

Both wild turkey and white-tailed deer obtain water from their diet but may use free-standing water when available. The stream on site would meet this need.

Wild turkey require forests, woodlands, and early successional plant communities for nesting. They forage in fields and herbaceous openings as well as woodlands and mature forests. They need tall shrubs or trees for roosting. White-tailed deer need dense woody vegetation as well as relatively tall early successional vegetation, including native grasses, forbs, and shrubs. So, both species require similar cover. While the current cover is adequate, more shrubs and trees could be needed.

One area of concern is the nonnative invasive species on the property. In the fields, lespedezas, bermudagrass, and kudzu are found. In the young forest, privet and chinaberry are also present.

Plan Implementation

A well-developed management plan will include the appropriate management practices, explaining how the various management practices selected will affect the habitat and/or the species, and acknowledge the management practices that may provide mutual benefits and any compromises necessary to meet the needs of each of the species. 

The focus of this section is to highlight the appropriate wildlife management practices needed for this site, based on the assessment of which requirements are present or lacking (from the previous section.). It is important for teams to choose the most impactful management practices and provide extensive details, as opposed to merely providing just a list of recommended wildlife management practices. Teams will want to describe where the practice will be applied; this can also be noted on the aerial map.

When listing the management practices that will be incorporated into the plan, be sure to explain what the practice is and why it is needed. Think about “what-why-how” when describing their intended actions – what is the management practice they are selecting, why are they selecting it, and how it will affect the ecosystem and two focal species.

– What: set-back succession throughout the forest
– Why: prescribed fires can maintain herbaceous groundcover in the longleaf pine ecosystem; eastern indigo snakes and gopher tortoise live in areas with sandy soils with an abundance of animal burrows and stump holes, and herbaceous groundcover provides protection for both species. Gopher tortoises eat grasses and legumes.
– How: set-back succession with prescribed fire kills the existing cover and stimulates fresh plant growth. Fire exposes the bare mineral soil required for seeds to germinate and protects young seedlings from disease.

If a specific practice has a specific frequency (how many times) or duration (how long) associated with it, that can be noted as well. For example, the do not feed wildlife management practice would occur indefinitely. However, a practice like forest management – regeneration where trees are harvested within a stand through various silvicultural methods with the intention of renewing and maintaining that forest stand may happen once, with the intention of an annual assessment to see if additional harvesting needs to occur.

When managing for wildlife, it’s likely that some compromises have to happen to meet the goals. Many times, teams forget to address any potential management compromises necessary to meet the needs of each species. For example, installing food plots for white-tailed deer could also benefit raccoon, which might be detrimental because raccoon is already abundant in the area. There may also be times when the implementation of certain practices can be mutually beneficial for both species; this should be noted as well. For example, removing the nonnative invasive vegetation would likely provide more diverse food or habitat options for multiple species, such as the barred owl and the red-cockaded woodpecker, potentially increasing their population.

Tip: When developing and implementing wildlife management plans, there is often more than one acceptable solution. Rather than a single “right” answer, managers must evaluate site conditions, management objectives, and available resources to determine the most appropriate practices. Some management actions may be considered high priority because they address the most critical needs of the property, while other practices may provide additional benefits but are less essential. Youth are encouraged to think critically, be creative, and provide detailed explanations that clearly justify their management recommendations.

An example of the plan implementation for a management plan could be:
Given the current conditions, our first priority is to establish suitable cover and food sources for the wild turkey and white-tailed deer. We will plant trees and shrubs, particularly those that produce hard and soft mast because they can provide cover as well as food. To encourage interspersion, we would plant some of the shrubs and trees in the fields. We’d also plant some of the shrubs and trees within the pine forest, with the goal of converting it to a mixed hardwood forest. The appropriate site preparation techniques will be performed. We realize that it is going to take several years before the shrubs and trees begin to produce mast, so we will also install food plots for both the white-tailed deer and the wild turkey. These food plots will increase the amount of food available and will be assessed on an annual basis if we will continue to plant them or not. The nonnative, invasive vegetation within both the field and forest also needs to be removed. Some of the observed species, especially kudzu, is reducing habitat quality by limiting herbaceous diversity. Removing the nonnative, invasive vegetation would likely provide more diverse food options, with the intent of increasing the populations. We would also begin edge feathering in areas where appropriate, where the field and forest meet. Edge feathering will increase forage availability around fields and enhance fawning/nesting cover for young. Finally, we would implement the practice of not feeding the wildlife. Although using commercial feeds might seem like a good idea, this could increase the populations of non-target species, like coyote, raccoon, squirrels, rodents, etc. Plus, this could also increase the risk of disease transmission.

Plan Evaluation

A well-developed management plan will present a realistic method or methods for monitoring the success of the recommendations. The management plan’s effect on populations and stated objectives will be assessed. 

The focus of this section is to share a summary of how the land manager will determine if and when the practices recommended in the previous section would be successful. For example, if prescribed fire was recommended to set-back succession and stimulate new plant growth, fresh vegetation would typically be visible within a few weeks after the burn, with increased plant abundance and coverage expected by the end of the first growing season.

This is also the section where information regarding the population of the two focal species will be shared. Many times, a wildlife or fish survey is recommended to monitor the potential increase or decrease in the population for the selected species. Senior contestants are especially encouraged to use specific details about what type of survey they would conduct and the frequency. For example, contestants may earn more points if they indicate that they would specifically conduct point counts monthly for the next six months to monitor the loggerhead shrike population, as opposed to just saying they would conduct a wildlife survey. Information about the best methods for population surveys for each species are listed in the national WHEP manual on the information page(s) about that species. Detailed information about wildlife and fish surveys are also found within the management plan section, too.

An example of the plan evaluation for a management plan could be:
Our focus is primarily about creating suitable cover and food sources for the wild turkey and the white-tailed deer. We intend to focus on planting shrubs and trees. Because it will likely be multiple years/growing seasons to see mast being produced, we intend to regularly observe these plants and assess their progress. For the food plots, we hope that both species will utilize these as extra food sources. We will install wildlife cameras at these areas and monitor use on a weekly basis.

Our goal is to increase the wild turkey and white-tailed deer populations, so that there are enough of each species to sustainably harvest during hunting seasons. The wildlife cameras at the food plots can help us estimate population density, sex ratio, and age structure. We also plan to install wildlife cameras in other locations at the property (particularly along the edges) to capture this population information. These additional cameras will be checked twice a month. We also plan to use autonomous recording units throughout the property to detect wild turkey. If our recommendations are successful, we should see increases in both populations.

Aerial Map

The third page of the management plan includes an aerial map. 

Youth are encouraged to use colored pencils to create the aerial map, which is particularly helpful when distinguishing the many features. When creating the aerial map, teams should consider:

– representing all major features including land in different successional stages (e.g., forest vs open field), bodies of water (e.g., lake, stream, etc.) and structures (e.g., building, roads, trails, etc.)
– clearly indicating where a wildlife management practice will be implemented (e.g., a rectangle labeled ‘install food plots’)

A map legend/key is highly encouraged. Teams should include, at minimum, 2 management practices on the aerial map. However, depending on the number of practices recommended, it is encouraged to include as many as possible.

An example of a well-developed map is below.

An example of a written wildlife management plan recommending forest management, control nonnative invasive vegetation. A map and a legend are also in the image.

 

Plan Presentation & General Tips

Overall quality and neatness of the management plan is assessed. The written plan should be well-organized and easy to follow. Using section headers that match the components of the rubric (i.e., background, plan development, plan implementation, and plan evaluation) is very helpful. Teams are provided blank paper, so they should learn the order of information in preparation for the contest. Having neat and legible handwriting is also helpful. Ensure the map and key/legend are present.

Try to use the correct vocabulary words instead of common, everyday language. The sentence “We will add trees and plants to give animals more food and places to hide,” can be enhanced to “We will enhance food and cover availability by establishing native mast-producing trees and increasing understory vegetation.”

Remember to add details, especially as it relates to the management practices selected. Some practices, like forest management and set-back succession have sub-practices and additional details that describe ‘how’ the practice would be implemented.

The most important part of the plan is helping the landowner achieve their objectives. Every recommendation should connect back to a stated goal. What does the landowner want to accomplish? How will the recommendation help achieve that goal?

Work together as a team to proofread and review the plan before submitting for evaluation.